After setback, Jagan mulls scrapping Legislative Council

A day after it suffered a humiliation by not getting two crucial bills on its plan of having three capitals passed by the Andhra Pradesh Legislative Council, the Y.S. Jaganmohan Reddy government on Thursday indicated it may abolish the Upper House of the Legislature.
“We need to seriously think whether we need to have such a House which appears to be functioning with only political motives. It is not mandatory to have the Council, which is our own creation, and it is only for our convenience. So let us discuss the issue further on Monday and take a decision on whether or not to continue the Council,” the chief minister told the Assembly on Thursday.
The chief minister was winding up an impromptu debate in the Assembly on what happened in the Council on Wednesday, where the chairman exercised his “discretionary power” under Rule 154 and referred the AP Decentralisation and Inclusive Development of All Regions Bill, 2020 and the APCRDA (Repeal) Bill to a select committee for deeper examination.
He also said there was no word by name “capital” in the Constitution and claimed there was no need for any legislation to decide a capital and a mere resolution would suffice.
With the principal opposition Telugu Desam Party (TDP) members staying away from the Assembly proceedings, the ruling YSR Congress MLAs came down heavily on Council Chairman MA Sharrif and Leader of the Opposition in the Council Yanamala Ramakrishnudu over the manner in which the proceedings were conducted and the two vital bills referred to a select committee, allegedly in transgression of rules.
“The chairman’s decision was against the rule book and the procedure he adopted was very unfortunate,” the chief minister said, adding the Council, “as the House of Elders, was there only to give suggestions” to the government.
“What will be the meaning of governance if the House of Elders does not allow good decisions to be taken in the interest of people and block enactment of laws? We need to seriously think about it... whether we should have such a House or do away with it,” Jagan added.
He said the council is preventing the passage of other important bills, including the one English medium schools, and asked if that was not against the country’s democratic spirit. He said a sum of Rs. 60 crore was being spent on the council per annum. Of the 28 states in the country, only six had functioning Legislative Councils, he noted.
Earlier in the day, Reddy held elaborate discussions with his Cabinet ministers and senior MLAs on the Council issue, in the wake of Wednesday's developments and the past experiences where two other Bills were returned, without approval, to the Assembly suggesting certain opposition-sponsored amendments.
The chief minister also reportedly discussed the issue with former attorney general Mukul Rohatgi, who has been appointed by the government to fight its case in the High Court on a batch of petitions, challenging the decision to have three capitals.
The Assembly, which was originally supposed to conclude its extended winter session on Wednesday, has now been extended indefinitely in view of the ongoing stalemate and the government’s latest thinking on the Legislative Council. The Assembly will resume its sitting on Monday. Though there is no official word on it yet, the Council is also expected to be reconvened from Monday as it was adjourned sine die on Wednesday.

Photo Gallery